100+ “I’ll Give You the Set-Up; You Guess the Punchline” – Hinge Answers

Humor is everything. It breaks the ice, skips the small talk, and gives major main character energy. That’s why I love this prompt — “I’ll give you the set-up; you guess the punchline.” It’s clever, cute, and the ultimate vibe check.

Below are 100+ setups that you can use to show off your wit or leave your match guessing (and smiling).

Classic Jokes That Never Fail

1. Why did the tomato blush?
2. Why don't skeletons fight each other?
3. Why did the scarecrow win an award?
4. What’s orange and sounds like a parrot?
5. What did one wall say to the other?
6. Why was the math book sad?
7. Why can’t your nose be 12 inches long?
8. Why did the golfer bring two pairs of pants?
9. What do you call cheese that isn’t yours?
10. What did the fish say when it hit the wall?

Flirty Setups That Spark a Smile

11. Are you a magician?
12. Why did I swipe right on you?
13. Do you believe in love at first sight…
14. Is your name Google?
15. What’s the best thing about messaging you first?
16. Are you French?
17. Why don’t we ever play hide and seek?
18. How do you know someone’s into you on Hinge?
19. Why is dating like a meme?
20. What do you and Wi-Fi have in common?

Smart but Silly

21. Why don’t scientists trust atoms?
22. What did the zero say to the eight?
23. Why did the physics teacher break up with biology?
24. Why are obtuse angles so annoying?
25. Why did the cell phone go to therapy?
26. Why don’t programmers like nature?
27. What’s a computer’s favorite snack?
28. Why did the iPhone go to school?
29. Why did the keyboard get promoted?
30. What’s a tech nerd’s favorite pickup line?

Animal Fun Setups

31. What do you call a fish with no eyes?
32. Why did the dog sit in the shade?
33. What do cats wear to sleep?
34. Why don’t crabs give to charity?
35. What’s a cow’s favorite subject?
36. Why did the chicken join a band?
37. What did the duck say when it bought lipstick?
38. Why was the frog so happy?
39. What do you call a bear with no teeth?
40. Why don’t bees use phones?

Everyday Life with a Twist

41. Why did my coffee file a complaint?
42. Why was the broom late to work?
43. Why can’t I be trusted at Target?
44. What happens when you don’t text back?
45. What did the microwave say to the popcorn?
46. What do you call laundry that folds itself?
47. Why is my fridge judging me?
48. What did my alarm clock say this morning?
49. Why does my car act up only on Mondays?
50. Why is Wi-Fi the most dramatic roommate?

Puns & Wordplay (The Good Kind)

51. I told my plants a joke…
52. Why don’t calendars get invited to parties?
53. What did the blanket say to the bed?
54. Why are ghosts bad at lying?
55. Why are pencils great secret keepers?
56. What did the ocean say to the beach?
57. What do you call fake spaghetti?
58. What’s the best day to go to the beach?
59. What did the grape say when it got stepped on?
60. Why did the bicycle fall over?

Holiday & Party Humor

61. What do elves do after school?
62. Why was the snowman looking through the carrots?
63. Why did the turkey cross the road?
64. What did the New Year’s resolution say on Jan 3rd?
65. Why do ghosts love Halloween?
66. What do you call a skeleton at a party?
67. Why did Santa apply for a loan?
68. What does Cupid eat for breakfast?
69. Why was the jack-o'-lantern smiling?
70. What’s a ghost’s favorite workout?

Dating-Specific Jokes (Relatable AF)

71. Why is dating like a Netflix trial?
72. Why did I delete Hinge and redownload it?
73. Why don’t I date chefs anymore?
74. What happens after a “hey” that goes nowhere?
75. What’s scarier than ghosting?
76. Why don’t I date people who say “I’m chill”?
77. What do I bring to the table?
78. Why do I swipe left on mirror selfies?
79. Why don’t I fall for travel photos anymore?
80. What’s worse than a bad date?

Offbeat & Random (for the Curious Ones)

81. What did the fork say to the spoon?
82. Why did the mirror avoid eye contact?
83. What do clouds gossip about?
84. What do shoes think about all day?
85. Why don’t elevators trust people?
86. What do dreams do when we’re awake?
87. What’s in your fridge thinking right now?
88. Why did the book call in sick?
89. What does your pillow know about you?
90. Why did my hoodie leave me?

Just Plain Weird and Wonderful

91. Why did the moon call the sun?
92. What does cereal dream about?
93. What’s my plant’s biggest fear?
94. What do ghosts use to write emails?
95. What’s a potato’s favorite workout?
96. Why did the lamp need therapy?
97. Why don’t aliens visit anymore?
98. Why did the peanut butter and jelly break up?
99. What did the charger say to the outlet?
100. Why did the mirror take a selfie?
101. Bonus: What did this list do to my Hinge profile?

Why This Prompt is a Secret Weapon

This prompt shows you're clever, fun, and approachable — without even trying. Whether your match laughs or replies with their own guess, you’ve already started something memorable.

Tips to Make It Even Better

1. Use setups that reflect your humor style
Are you flirty, punny, sarcastic, or deep? Pick a lane or mix them up!

2. Leave some punchlines open
Let them guess — it becomes instant banter and a reason to reply.

Answers To More Hinge Prompts 😊

• My Best Celebrity Impression- Hinge Answers
• Guess the Song- Hinge Answers
• My Favourite Line from A Film- Hinge Answers